He's just a cardboard vessel that the 'plot' throws around. I couldn't even tell you what Alex's character is like. Really! She can slip in as a cleaner or a kitchen helper.Īlso, a thing of note: the only PoC in this book was the villain. The whole novel had this sexist voice, and the worst of it is that this is set in the current time. I kid you not, this is actually in the book. She might be able to slip in as a cleaner or a kitchen helper.'' We were considering sending down a woman. Someone who can look around and report back without being seen. 'We have to send someone in who won't be noticed. But before I go into large-scale issues, I'd like to mention that these are the paragraphs that immediately set me against this book: It had to be good, right? It happened with the Pendragon books, it'll happen here too, yeah?Īnd then everything after those pages was complete nonsense. I mean, I'd seen it EVERYWHERE, after all. The first few pages were fine-I was all prepared to get sucked into this book. You know how there are those books that you see everywhere, in every library, in every bookstore, and then one day you just break down and pick it up? This is one of those books. So do I add it to the books to be discarded and face alienating my students with my conservatism? Do I want a library full of 'classic novels' that no one will read? Or do I continue to buy and shelve books like the Alex Rider series and Wimpy Kid series which are immensely popular but set bad examples for their audience? However, kids who don't like to read will read Alex Rider. They get enough of this is every other form of media. I think the first one (I cannot testify for the rest of the series as I haven't read them) is full of all the things that I do not want to promote in the collection for which I am responsible: violence, consumerism, and a disrespectful protagonist. This book left me very conflicted as a children's librarian. And then there is Alex himself, who appears to me to be an arrogant, showboating, hotshot who thinks he can do anything on his own. And the car details! Give me a break! Most of the kids and teens reading this have no clue what the differences between engines are. Why feed into this consumerist crap, especially for a young audience that is already so consumed with having to have what is cool.

I hate all the label dropping! Do we need to know that our character wears Nike and Gap? Absolutely not.

I just wish Horowitz had written it with his readers in mind as the young, impressionable audience that they are.

I can see the appeal: espionage, a kid caught in everyone else's plans, having to take care of himself while saving the world. I read this book because it is so popular with my students.

Stormbreaker horowitz